 |  |
Soccer
| Soccer | Year | Athlete | Team | Notes |
| Men's | 1973 | Mickey Rooney | HM | NCAA |
| Men's | 1974 | Mickey Rooney | 1 | NCAA |
| Men's | 1975 | Jose Neves | 2 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1977 | Tad Delorm | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1977 | Trevor Franklin | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1978 | Trevor Franklin | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1978 | Sigfried Trocha | 2 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1978 | Paul Trocki | 2 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1978 | Mike Silverman | HM | NAIA |
| Men's | 1980 | Kyle Dietrich | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1980 | Tony Pierce | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1980 | Ian Wilson | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1981 | Kyle Dietrich | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1981 | Ian Wilson | 1 | NAIA |
| Men's | 1981 | Kevin Forgeron |
HM |
NAIA |
| Men's | 1981 | John McCully | HM | NAIA |
| Men's | 1982 | John McCully | 2 | NSCAA |
| Men's | 1983 | Sean Kenny | 1 | NSCAA |
| Men's | 1983 | John McCully | 1 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 1983 | Laurie St. Pierre | 3 | NSCAA |
| Men's | 1984 | Sean Kenny | 2 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 1989 | Denise Lyons | 1 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 1990 | Alison Foley | 1 | NSCAA |
| Men's | 1991 | Osvaldo Molina | 2 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 1993 | Allyson Meler | 2 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 1994 | Heather Boisvere | 1 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 1996 | Heather Boisvere | 2 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 1998 | Amy Zombeck | 2 | NSCAA |
| Men's | 1999 | Lakota Denton | 2 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 2002 | Erin Lester | 2 | NSCAA |
| Women's | 2003 | Jennifer Ortisi | 2 | NSCAA |
