 |  |
Baseball
| Year | Athlete | Team | Notes | Position |
| 2008 | Greg Ford | HM | D3baseball.com | Utility |
| 2009 | Bobby Doyon | 1 | D3baseball.com | Outfield |
| 2009 | Bobby Doyon | 2 | ABCA | Outfield |
| 2010 | Bobby Doyon | HM | D3baseball.com | Outfield |
| NCAA Gold Glove | Athlete | Team | Notes | Position |
| 2008 | Jamie Chevalier | 1 | ABCA/Rawling Division III |
2nd Base |
